COST ANALYSIS

Home Contents Contact us

Up ] Boiler fouling & deposits ]

 

ECONOMICS OF USING SAPEC

 

 SAPEC CAN ONLY SAVE MONEY IF A BOILER SUFFERS FROM FIRESIDE FOULING.

The success of SAPEC is based on pre-trial inspections. There are no potential savings unless fouling deposits are present on the heat transfer surfaces.

Boiler fouling costs money.

Increases fuel costs per kg of steam produced.
Reduces boiler operating periods between cleans.
Increases boiler downtime
Increases boiler cleaning costs
Increases Maintenance costs.

 Boiler Fouling  is not new, for years engineers have attempted to reduce boiler fouling through a number of different methods, all of which represent an extra cost:

Using better quality coals that often tend to be more expensive
More regular cleaning regimes.
Increased Soot-blowing.
Changing from Coal to alternative fuels..

 SAPEC REPRESENTS A CHEMICAL SOLUTION FOR A CHEMICAL PROBLEM.

Flue-side fouling causes the formation of heat resistant bonded deposits on the heat transfer surfaces of the boiler which are analogous to water-side scale and like them, reduce the boiler heat transfer rate, the boiler must then operate for longer periods in order to restore the system to equilibrium, thereby using excess  fuel for the same loading. 

The prevention and control of these deposits will therefore achieve a significant saving in fuel and can play an important role in Energy Management, apart from the  additional savings due to easier and less frequent cleaning.

The effect of boiler fouling on the heat transfer rate is well documented. for example a 1mm thick deposit will reduce the heat transfer rate by 10 %. A 2mm thick deposit will reduce it by 25 %. The resultant increase in fuel consumption will be of the order of 2.5% & 4.5% respectively, the actual figures will vary but it is important to observe the order of magnitude, it is clear that, what would be considered " a very small amount of fouling(1mm)" has a significant effect on the efficiency of a boiler.

The effect of boiler fouling on the heat transfer rate is illustrated below:

ECONOMICS OF USING SAPEC.

SAPEC reduces boiler  fouling problems in boilers using all types and qualities of coals. 

To save a net 5% SAPEC only needs to reduce the deposition by just over 2mm. 

SAPEC allows customers to use lower grade coals

In South Africa SAPEC has allowed customers to get grade A performance from grade B coals. The price difference can often be as much as 20%-25%.with often no difference in calorific value. This price difference is a recognition of the costs of boiler fouling. So far SAPEC has allowed customers to reduce there coal bill by as much as 18% by switching coals in conjunction with the SAPEC treatment program.

Reduced Downtime

Reduced cleaning requirements and quicker cleaning result in reduced downtime.

Easier Cleaning

SAPEC prevents the formation of bonded deposits any remaining deposits are soft and easily removed.

No Need for Abrasive Cleaning methods

Boiler cleaning becomes far easier, allowing less abrasive de-scaling techniques to be used, this reduces wear

Prior to SAPEC the only means of controlling fouling was by frequent cleaning, or by reducing the individual boilers load factor, both have the effect of reducing efficiency losses but at a cost, fouling still occurs with the resultant reduction in heat transfer rate, Further the effect of abrasive cleaning methods on the boiler structure inevitably leads to more tube failures, the cost of the cleaning, and the consequent lack of boiler availability. Logically it is far more advantageous to prevent fouling deposits rather than remove them.